October 24, 2026
Bonus Content: American Express Beat Earnings and Still Fell 3.7%
Heads up:
If you still haven’t downloaded your copy of The Retirement Trade, you’d better grab it now.
I’m eventually planning to move this book behind a paywall.
So the smart thing to do right now is download the book and save it to your phone or computer. This way you’ll have your copy of the guide saved no matter what it costs in the future.
Grab it here:
Expiring Download Link: The Retirement Trade (Free pdf)
To your success,
Dave Aquino
Basecamp Trading
P.S. Be sure to pay close attention to page 6, where I show an example of making $1,160 in less than an hour from a retirement trade on a popular tech company. Ticker & full strategy revealed on page 6 here.
American Express Beat Earnings and Still Fell 3.7%
Markets don’t need a miss to sell a stock. They only need a reason. American Express gave them one on Friday, and the fact that it came wrapped inside a clean earnings beat makes it worth understanding precisely.
American Express beat analyst earnings expectations but missed on revenue in its Q3 2026 results. The company reported adjusted EPS of $4.68 versus the $4.50 consensus estimate, while revenue of $20.06 billion fell short of the $20.12 billion estimate by roughly $60 million. Revenue grew 8.9% year over year. Adjusted EPS climbed 13% from $4.14 a year ago. By any traditional scorecard, that is a solid quarter.
The stock closed down 3.7%.
What the Numbers Actually Said
Net card fees grew 16% year over year, the fastest-growing revenue line. Net interest income rose 10% year over year, and total balances grew 8%. Management reaffirmed full-year revenue growth guidance of about 10% (FX-adjusted) and raised full-year adjusted EPS guidance to $17.60 to $17.90. The company returned $2.2 billion to shareholders through buybacks and dividends.
So why the selloff? Three things hit simultaneously. Total card spending reached $454 billion, below the $456.9 billion estimate. The volume shortfall was partly attributed to the company’s exit from certain small business co-branded card partnerships. And then there was the workforce announcement: American Express said it would eliminate roughly 5% of its workforce, or about 3,500 roles, alongside its Q3 results. According to CNBC, the cuts are the company’s first major reduction in about a decade. CEO Stephen Squeri cited a $336 million restructuring charge aimed at making the company more agile, with CFO Christophe Le Caillec framing the goal as reducing layers to automate work and prepare for AI.
Expectations vs. Reaction
This is not about whether American Express is a good business. It clearly is. This is about what the market had already priced in and what the options market flagged going in.
Ahead of earnings, the options market priced in an implied move of roughly ±3.80% for AXP. The realized move of 3.7% landed almost exactly at the implied boundary, meaning volatility sellers collected near maximum premium while directional bulls absorbed a loss. Implied volatility heading into the release was 38.6%, with a one-year IV rank of 37.9. That rank is mid-range: not screaming expensive, not cheap. Premium sellers had a workable edge; it came through.
Post-earnings, with the event resolved, IV will compress toward the 25% range seen in less eventful periods. That compression reshapes the opportunity set for the next structured position.
Sector Read: Visa on Deck Tuesday
Visa will report its fiscal fourth quarter and full-year 2026 financial results on Tuesday, October 27, 2026. The consensus EPS estimate for Visa’s Q4 stands at $3.44, on revenue of $12.09 billion. The market has priced in an earnings reaction of ±2.96% for Visa. Mastercard follows shortly after. The AXP reaction matters for how traders position around both: if spend volume softness is a company-specific story tied to co-brand exits, Visa may trade through cleanly. If it reflects broader consumer deceleration, the sector read gets darker fast.
Structured Trade Framework
Bull case (AXP stabilization): If you believe the workforce reduction is a genuine margin catalyst and the spend miss was structural rather than cyclical, a defined-risk bull put spread below current price allows participation in a recovery while capping downside. The IV compression post-event lowers the cost of protection.
Bear case (volume deterioration): For traders expecting spend growth to continue fading, a bear call spread above the $320 resistance level captures continued weakness. The 52-week range runs $290.97 to $387.49, so there is meaningful room to the downside before structural support.
Neutral case (Visa as the cleaner vehicle): A defined-risk iron condor on Visa into Tuesday’s report, structured around the ±2.96% implied move, isolates the event premium without carrying the sector overhang that now sits on AXP.
Checklist
- AXP adjusted EPS: $4.68 vs. $4.50 consensus. Beat confirmed.
- AXP revenue: $20.06B vs. $20.12B consensus. Miss confirmed.
- Card spending volume: $454B vs. $456.9B expected. Below consensus.
- Restructuring charge: $336M. Workforce reduction: ~5%, about 3,500 roles.
- Full-year adjusted EPS guidance raised to $17.60–$17.90. Full-year revenue growth guidance reaffirmed at about 10% (FX-adjusted).
- AXP IV rank at earnings: 37.9. Implied move: ±3.80%. Realized: ~3.7%.
- Visa reports October 27, after close. Consensus EPS: $3.44. Implied move: ±2.96%.
- Monitor whether AXP’s spend miss is confirmed or contradicted by Visa’s network volume data.
